Skip to content

Advertisment

Will someone tell Liz Jones to shut up?

Mon, 27 July 2009 | Gigi Eligoloff

Another day, another vitriolic rant against mothers, this time from the (mostly poisoned) pen of over-sharer and journalist Liz Jones in the Daily Mail. Just to give you a flavour if you can't be bothered to click the link (and we know you're busy) here's a snippet -

"The other day, a group of mums was stood in my garden  -  don't ask me why  -  and one reached up to scratch her head, probably at me and my hedonistic lifestyle, and I caught sight of her stomach with its texture and hue of cold, congealed porridge and I couldn't help but stare, aghast."

Actually the really sad part of this seemingly spontaneous spew against mothers and motherhood, is that it's all in aid of flogging Jones's new book - 'Sad, single and now living in a field' (aka The Exmoor Files: How I Lost A Husband And Found Rural Bliss). Jones, in the course of protesting once again on exactly why she didn't have children (did we miss someone asking her to have them?), continues her miserable moan on mothers who leave the office at 6pm, mothers who shop for anything but Prada in their lunch hour, and mothers who get untold riches from the family-promoting government as an added incentive to breed. She also finds time for a quick grumble about a 'friend' who momentarily misplaced her child on Jones' sprawling Somerset estate and asked (with a slight waver of panic) whether there was a pond in the grounds. Oh yes Liz - how irritating that must have been for you.

As a mother of one, in my early forties (unlike Liz I don't actually knock ten years off my age) I'm sure I'm not alone in having been an avid reader of her columns in You Magazine. I've even been known to read her celebrity interviews although I did have to draw the line at her fashion pieces - unless you're a teenage goth you really shouldn't sport dyed long black hair. It's wierd, witchy and not very flattering. But the dye job is by the by because now it's all over. Liz Jones and I are finished.

Targetting mothers whom she helpfully clumps into one obsessive, stressed, tired, badly- dressed population of dullards, is just one self-obsessed bleat too many. Liz, we don't care if you buy over-priced cashmere blankets and prawns for your cat-babies, or merrily spend the equivalent of our yearly mortgage payments on vet's fees for your knackered race horse. Because it's none of our business. As mothers - the one thing we can never ever talk about is how we might feel about women who do not have children. And neither would we want to. We aren't asking you to babysit, care or even register our lives, our children, or the sometimes extrordinarily brave struggles of some parents that get way more than they bargained for when they get knocked up. But we are happy for our children to grow up to be the tax payers who will keep the NHS going for you (and us) when we're old and infirm. 

In fact we're so over you we were thinking of posting the demise of our affection (and loyalty) on site de jour relationshipobit.com. Almost, but not quite - you see we're far too busy getting on with our own lives to spend anymore time moaning about yours. You've managed to alienate the very readers who might have been happy to shell out £12.99 on your book. Perhaps it's a curious case of a back-firing PR? Who knows.

Liz Jones has a book coming out. Don't buy it, she sucks. 

See all The Rock Report

Bookmark and Share

Comments - 15 and counting...

I love that article, well said! Any mother commenting on a woman without children would be scowled at for being totally insensitive.

I used to work regular 18 hour days, but this didn't even get close to the hard work of becoming a mum. Even for those of us lucky enough to have healthy children it is a tough job, as you said, let along those who get a "more than they bargained for".

I don't think anyone has a chance of understanding what it is like unless they have children of their own, but that doesn't give them the right to write us all off in that way. We need more people supporting mums (see www.mumspath.co.uk) not people making us feel worse than we sometimes already do!

I definitely won't be buying her book - I did the single life, enjoyed it, but despite the hard work it doesn't come anywhere close to how much I love being a mum.

Posted by: TracyG | 28 July 2009

easy ladies - liz jones is paid to be contentious; isn't that the real issue here and the fact that without her "edge" and snide, she'd be dumped by her editor/publisher....perhaps critisism should go beyond ms jones and, instead, be focussed on those who encourage her to write in such a manner ?

Posted by: himindoors | 8 August 2009

One of the best things I have read on t'internet for ages! Thank you! Here's another one, by the way, I think you'll like it, by the redoutable Jane at Diary of a Desperate Exmoor woman:

http://exmoorjane.blogspot.com/2009/06/leave-dulverton-alone-liz-jones.html

My own rather dull and simplistic view is that it breaks my heart to see such crass, nasty thoughtless and shitty bile against any group of women - mums or otherwise.

My belly is as big as a bloody great vat of porridge but I'm still getting plenty.

Am adding your site to the resources over at our family travel blog. Thanks again for a great read.

Posted by: Linda | 28 July 2009

Thanks so much for feedback. I'll check out the link too!
x

Posted by: gigi | 29 July 2009

I couldn't agree more Gigi great article, god knows why the sour faced old bat is making hay for christ sake because she's got more chance of being aloud to adopting a baby from Malawi than actually rolling around in said hay with any consenting male! Sorry if my tone is a little mean but the woman is so infuriating i mean who bloody cares about her organic M&S bought carrot battons....like the horse is going to refuse Aldi ones the silly troll!

Posted by: Wife of Bold | 29 July 2009

My 'favouritest' ever read on here that stopped me lurking on here and make a comment. Liz suffers with what I call Those Who Doth Protest Too Much syndrome. Talk out of your arse enough by saying a load of twaddle that actually really conveys that really convinces me that she is a miserable 'so-and-so' who takes cheap shots at mums. Please Liz - go suck a carrot or something but just stop the frickin whining!

Posted by: Nat Lue | 30 July 2009

Good grief, that ridiculous article made my blood boil. What was the point of it in the first place? If this woman is so despising of children and mothers (no attack on fathers I notice) why on earth does she remain friends with the people in the article?

Posted by: that_kat | 30 July 2009

Liz Jones is a trainwreck of a woman, we should pity her!
I'd rather have a belly that resembles cold porridge than live her life.
Allyson the soaplady
http://www.bellinghamsoapcompany.co.uk

Posted by: allybsc | 31 July 2009

Well, I am a mum but I loved the article and agree with a lot of the feelings expressed by Liz Jones. I also thought the article was honest and humorous - something she has in common with those at Mums Rock.

I find puppies far more lovely than babies. I don't really like other people's children, especially when they have snot running down their faces. I love my daughter but I too look aghast at my porridge belly and I dread being at social gatherings where everyone has their four children in tow.

The bit that made me laugh out-loud was the mother diluting the fresh orange juice. So true and hilarious! Sometimes I think that parents forget how uninteresting parenting can be to non-parents. I know how all-consuming it is but that doesn't make it fascinating or appealing to others. Similarly, non-parents assume that they know all about child rearing and they don't have a clue until it happens to them.

I'm not at all upset that Liz would find me a bit boring. Fair enough, sometimes parenting is a bit boring - like any job. I'm hoping to become more interesting again once the under 5's stage is over....

Posted by: Pram.Face | 3 August 2009

Well, I am a mum but I loved the article and agree with a lot of the feelings expressed by Liz Jones. I also thought the article was honest and humorous - something she has in common with those at Mums Rock.

I find puppies far more lovely than babies. I don't really like other people's children, especially when they have snot running down their faces. I love my daughter but I too look aghast at my porridge belly and I dread being at social gatherings where everyone has their four children in tow.

The bit that made me laugh out-loud was the mother diluting the fresh orange juice. So true and hilarious! Sometimes I think that parents forget how uninteresting parenting can be to non-parents. I know how all-consuming it is but that doesn't make it fascinating or appealing to others. Similarly, non-parents assume that they know all about child rearing and they don't have a clue until it happens to them.

I'm not at all upset that Liz would find me a bit boring. Fair enough, sometimes parenting is a bit boring - like any job. I'm hoping to become more interesting again once the under 5's stage is over....

Posted by: Pram.Face | 3 August 2009

Gigi, what a brilliant column! I loved it. I'm not too bad on the porridge belly front, but do have weird jelly like triangular upper arms. I picked up my son and carried him on my hip for about 9 years on my hips. Now he's the same size as me and I can't carry him, I need a new toning regime. I hope she has a pop at fat-armed people next week. I'll complain about discrimination if she doesn't.

Posted by: Maria Roberts | 4 August 2009

The latest 'news' from Planet Jones (my sources tell me) is that Liz has taken to wearing a Burka.

Might this be, not in support of Lubna Hussein the Sudanese woman facing a flogging for wearing trousers, but in fact to gain some respite from all the disapproving mummies pointing the finger?!? hmmmm nice try lady but we've got your number.

Posted by: gigi | 9 August 2009

Brilliant Gigi, so well said. Just wanted to add:

Liz Jones has a book coming out. Don't buy it, she sucks...

but only when she's desperate to keep a man - the ultimate in subservient self-loathing, and she actually admits to it and thinks her honesty will make people like her.

It just made me pity her even more.

Posted by: funkybabymama | 10 August 2009

I rather like the presence of Liz Jones because she provokes a reaction in me the same way Julie Burchill did during her hey-day. And horror - which I feel about her literary audacity, is far more satisfying than the uninspired "so-what?" the majority of mainstream women's journalism leaves me with these days.

She may put down absolutely everyone, but its balanced out - her self-criticism is really harsh. Rather than feel insulted by her I almost feel creeping smugness that I don't live her life. I read an interview in Grazia with her last week where she said she had no friends anymore, there was nothing left to lose cos she'd lost it all through her column writing - but its been her choice.

I only wish her You column would contain less of the boring anecdotes about her animal sanctuary. Now that REALLY turns me off.

Posted by: Tabitha Twitchett | 11 August 2009

Oh yes she surmises the septic single - singular, hardbitten and raging against everyone except herself. I read an interview with her last week and she's made herself incredibly unpopular but seems to relish it...weird.

Posted by: nixdminx | 22 August 2009

Advertisement